Each episode focuses on one guest, who, in whatever way, has been discredited and is therefore 'the black sheep'. First, the guest is interviewed by Diepman; this is often accompanied by illustrative TV fragments that are shown. After this, the guest is given the opportunity to tell his or her side of the matter. Behind a fence are supporters and opponents of the person in question, 'the white sheep', who take turns speaking their pros or cons for or against the guest. After this, Diepman confronts her guest with these statements, and the guest is given the opportunity to respond.