The documentary unravels Wade Wilson's 2019 crime spree in Cape Coral, Florida, where he brutally murdered Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz within hours. Melton was strangled in her bed, and hours later, Ruiz was lured into her car, strangled, and run over multiple times. Wilson showed no remorse after his arrest, telling authorities he would "do it again." The series examines why a man who committed unimaginable violence developed such a dedicated online following, contrasting this online obsession with the very real, horrific violence he inflicted on his victims.