Valentine plot
"Remember that kid everyone ignored on Valentine’s Day? — He remembers you."
In the late 1980s, at a Valentine's Day school dance, unpopular nerd Jeremy Melton is laughed at by all five girls he asks to dance, except Dorothy. Moments later they are kissing in a corner. Some bullies catch them and make fun of them, whereupon Dorothy says that Jeremy has been harassing her. The young man is beaten up. Some twelve years later, the five girls are in their twenties and suddenly receive sickly Valentine's cards signed with JM. Would Jeremy Melton be back? Or is it someone else terrifying the girls?