Introverted songwriter Hannah Wells has a crush on a musician, but he doesn't reciprocate her interest. To attract his attention, she strikes a deal with Garrett Graham, the popular star of the hockey team. She tutors him for an important exam in exchange for a "fake relationship" to make her crush jealous. What starts as a business arrangement soon turns into a deep and passionate romance when Garrett realizes that he doesn't want to keep their relationship fake at all.